Posted by Editor on February 11th, 2008
Posted In:
Baby Boomers,
Consumers,
Crash Prophets,
Credit,
Economy,
Employment,
Financial Sector,
Home Prices,
Housing,
Recession,
Stimulus Package,
Stocks,
Surveys,
Unemployment
As the United States teeters on the brink of recession, some wonder if the Baby Boomers can rescue us through their propensity to spend. A Reuters piece that appeared in the New Zealand Herald on February 8 tried to answer this question. According to Reuters:
Retirement is fast approaching for many of the 76 million-strong generation born in the nearly two decades following World War II. The oldest members of that group turn 62 this year, which is the earliest age to collect Social Security retirement benefits.
Much of their savings are tied up in home equity and sharemarket investments, both of which are now under pressure as the housing and financial sectors stumble. The housing slump and subsequent credit contraction have already taken a toll on US spending and employment, leading many economists to conclude that a recession is close at hand.
David Rosenberg, an economist with Merrill Lynch in New York, told Reuters:
In the early 1980s, early 1990s and the last recession in 2001, as rough as it was for the economy, the boomer could still be relied upon to put a floor under the consumer.
A powerful spending force for the past three decades, the Baby Boomers boast about $3 trillion in annual income, according to the AARP. On the flipside, Reuters claims they have been a big reason for the miserable U.S. savings rate of close to zero, as they took advantage of housing and investment wealth to fund their lifestyles. As this wealth shrinks, Boomers may cut back on spending to rebuild their nest eggs. There is evidence to support this scenario. According to Reuters:
After the technology bubble burst, leading to the 2001 recession, AARP surveyed investors aged 50 to 70 on how they were coping with the sharemarket slide. More than three-quarters of those polled said they had lost money in stocks, mutual funds or other investment accounts. Of those, two-thirds said they had adjusted their lifestyle as a result, including budgeting more carefully, taking fewer holidays and putting off major purchases.
As a result, Rosenberg, Merrill Lynch’s North American economist, now expects the worst consumer recession since 1980 as the Boomers cut back on spending.
The fact that the generation’s youngest members are still in their 40s (which puts them in the peak of their spending years) offers some hope. However, roughly two-thirds of the Boomers are 50 or older.
While recent stock market losses are nowhere near as bad as they were earlier this decade, the housing market is another story. Dean Baker, economist and co-director for the Center for Economic and Policy Research in Washington, D.C., said the present situation in housing is far worse, and more worrisome as homes account for a heftier chunk of savings. Baker explained:
We’re talking about a massive loss of wealth. Prices are just plummeting. You have someone who’s in their 50s, maybe even 60s, and they’re counting on the equity in their home to be a major source of their wealth in retirement. They just saw their home price fall 15 per cent. They’re in real trouble.
Yet, a Reuters/Zogby poll conducted in mid-January still found Americans aged 50 to 64 felt “pretty good” about their financial situation. Nearly 60% rated their financial situation “good” or “excellent,” making them more optimistic than the overall population. The reality is, older workers are “particularly vulnerable” in downturns. According to the article:
Baker says worries about job security and paying for retirement may prompt boomers to pocket rather than spend any rebates they receive as part of a stimulus package of some US$150 billion moving its way through Congress. “If people do end up saving it, obviously it doesn’t provide very much stimulus,” he says.
In another blow to Boomer wealth, on February 5 MarketWatch reported that the vast amount of wealth that was to be transferred between the “greatest generation” and the Baby Boomers is now looking to be a bust. Thomas Kostigen wrote that the $17 trillion that is supposed to change hands in the next 20 years may be far less due to longer life expectancies, increased medical costs, and estate taxes. According to a new Consumer Wealth research report by Tiburon Strategic Advisors:
The World War II generation wealth transfer has been less impressive than many predicted, and it likely will not grow much further…
The median value of a baby boomer’s inheritance is $48,000; very few have received more than $100,000. Specifically, only 2% of those baby boomers who received an inheritance received more than $100,000. Furthermore, the coming wealth transfer faces several limiting factors, including immediate spending, longer time in retirement, health-care costs, taxes and wealth concentration.
Sphere: Related Content